Is it healthy for a woman to eat 1200 calories a day?

Dramatically cutting calories can have unexpected health effects
Dramatically cutting calories can have unexpected health effects
(Getty Images/iStockphoto)

Is it safe to eat 1,200 calories a day?

'For some women it could temporarily shut down their fertility.'

Kashmira Gander
Wednesday 05 October 2016 12:40
Comments

Could you survive on 1,200 calories per day?

That's the potentially dangerous challenge thousands of people are setting themselves in pursuit of the perfect body.

Countless apparent fitness gurus swear by the saying "1,200 is plenty", while the indulgences of the holiday season have caused Google searches of 1,200 calories to spike every January since 2005.

But restricting food can impact fertility and cause anxiety, a dietitian has warned.

There is, of course, a Reddit community devoted to the diet, where users share images of their neat and colourful but sparse meals.

However, nutrition expert Ursual Philpot, a spokesperson for the British Dietetic Association, has warned against this approach to eating.

While 1,200 is the minimum level of calories that the average person can survive on without the body going into starvation mode, that does not mean it is healthy, she told The Independent.

  • Eating a Mediterranean diet could help lower risk of heart disease in Britons
  • These side-by-side photos expose a major misconception about dieting
  • Mediterranean diet better than statins at combatting heart disease, study says
  • Why you should never try a fad diet- in two charts

An older person who is inactive or an overweight person may be able to eat 1,200 a day, she said. But there is no one size fits all solution for diet, and it is difficult to get the right level of nutrients with a strict regime unless a person carefully plans their meals.

On a 1,200 calorie diet, your body has to make adjustments. You cant live optimally on that. If you are young and active, you would lose weight and fat over time, but your body would make metabolic adjustments.

"You might get cold hands and feet more easily, and you would be preoccupied with food a lot of the time. You would feel anxious, and you wouldnt feel well overall.

"For some women it could temporarily shut down their fertility."

She explained that calorie recommendations should simply be seen as a starting point for considering what to eat.

It is like saying all men should wear size 9 shoes. You get people who can live on 1,200 and others who need 2,400.

It depends on how you feel. If you feel dreadful, tired, cold, preoccupied with eating and food, and a bit spaced out and dizzy then it is way too low.

Show all 11

Celeriac root

We had a kale obsession in 2015, but 2016s vegetable sine qua non is predicted to be the knobbly celeriac root. Celeriac milk (Tom Hunt at Poco in Bristol serves it with winter mussels and wild water celery), celeriac cooked in Galician beef fat (from Adam Rawson of Pachamama, hot new chef in the capital) and salt-baked celeriac (to be found in Matthew and Iain Penningtons kitchens at The Ethicurean in the West Country) are just a few examples.

Getty Images

Middle Eastern food

The Middle Eastern Vegetarian Cookbook (£24.95, Phaidon) by grand-dame Salma Hage, author of the bestseller The Lebanese Kitchen (whose halva is pictured here), is out in April

© Liz & Max Haarala Hamilton

Non-alcoholic cocktails

Grain Store mixologist Tony Conigliaro has created Roman Redhead, a riot of red grape juice, beetroot, pale ale and verjus, and Rose Iced Tea (black tea, rose petals, anise essence, pictured here)

Gin

The discerning will be slurping Hepple gin from chef Valentine Warner and cocktail guru Nick Strangeway which is punctuated with bog-myrtle nuances

Argyll and Bute

Restaurant followers are getting in a froth about Pam Brunton in Scotland, who opened the Inver restaurant in Argyll and Bute to acclaim last year

Andy Olivers Som Saa

One of the most eagerly awaited restaurants of 2016 will be the permanent incarnation of Andy Olivers remarkable pop-up Som Saa opening very soon in east London. Oliver, who worked at Thai god David Thompsons Nahm in Bangkok, raised a whopping £700,000 through crowdfunding, and is renowned for his piquant Thai flavours and obsessive attention to detail, including in his home ferments and DIY coconut cream

© Adam Weatherley

Venison

Another ruminant in vogue is venison, with Sainsburys doubling its line for 2016. It provides a protein-packed punch, with B vitamins and iron, and its low in fat. Its entry into the mainstream is in part thanks to the Scottish restaurant Mac and Wild, just opened in London, whose Celtic head chef Andy Waugh (who also runs the Wild Game Co) has been touting it as street food for years (his venison burger pictured here)

Goat

From Brett Grahams The Ledbury to Angela Hartnetts kitchens at Lime Wood Hotel in the New Forest, Cabrito is the go-to goat supplier among the chef cognoscenti (roasted loin of kid pictured here) but this year, domestic cooks can get in on the action, as Sushila Moles and James Whetlor of Cabrito offer their meat through Ocado

Mike Lusmore / mikelusmore.com

Coffee

Coffee sage George Crawford is launching the much-anticipated Cupsmith with his partner, Emma. Crawford believes that 2016 is the year purist coffee will finally meet the masses; Cupsmiths mission will be to make craft coffee as popular as craft beer on the high street. The company roasts Arabica beans in small batches, improving its quality but sells it online, at cupsmith.com, in an approachable way: expect cheerful packaging and names such as Afternoon Reviver Coffee (designed for drinking with milk no matter how uncouth, most of us want milk) and Glorious Espresso

Julia Conway

120-day-old steak

Hanging meat for extremely long lengths of time has become an art. In Cumbria, Lake Road Kitchens James Cross is plating up 120-day-old steak (pictured here). The beef is from influential ager Dan Austin of Lake District Farmers, who is currently investigating the individual bacterial cultures that go into this maturing process

Lotus root

Diners can expect root-to-stem dining - cue the full lotus deployed by the Michelin-starred Indian Benares in its kamal kakdi aur paneer korma

Getty Images

The food that individuals should eat also differs, she added. An active person should eat fat and carbohydrates, while someone who is overweight may be able to lose weight with a low carbohydrate and high protein diet.

"If I had to recommended a diet, I would say the Mediterranean with a moderate amount of low GI slow release carbohydrates, high quality protein, lots of vegeteables, olive oil, oily fish, nuts and legumes," she said. "But how much a person should eat is highly dependent on factors including age, genetics and activity levels.

Those aiming to lose weight should aim to shed between three to 10 per cent of their body weight to avoid gaining the weight back.

Be sensible. The populations that are slimmest and healthiest dont live of 1,200 calories, they dont cut carbs, they dont blend their own green milkshakes. Think about the bigger picture here and think about health and longevity and enjoying food.

"If a diet has worked for one person that does not mean that is the way that everyone should be eating.

Register for free to continue reading

Registration is a free and easy way to support our truly independent journalism

By registering, you will also enjoy limited access to Premium articles, exclusive newsletters, commenting, and virtual events with our leading journalists

Email
Please enter a valid email
Please enter a valid email
Password
Must be at least 6 characters, include an upper and lower case character and a number
Must be at least 6 characters, include an upper and lower case character and a number
Must be at least 6 characters, include an upper and lower case character and a number
First name
Please enter your first name
Special characters arent allowed
Please enter a name between 1 and 40 characters
Last name
Please enter your last name
Special characters arent allowed
Please enter a name between 1 and 40 characters
You must be over 18 years old to register
You must be over 18 years old to register
Year of birth
I would like to be emailed about offers, events and updates from The Independent.
Read ourPrivacy notice
Opt-out-policy
You can opt-out at any time by signing in to your account to manage your preferences. Each email has a link to unsubscribe.

{{#verifyErrors}} {{message}} {{/verifyErrors}} {{^verifyErrors}} {{message}} {{/verifyErrors}}

RegisterI'll try later

Already have an account? sign in

By clicking Register you confirm that your data has been entered correctly and you have read and agree to ourTerms of use,Cookie policyandPrivacy notice.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the GooglePrivacy policyandTerms of serviceapply.

More about

HealthdietFoodFitnesswell-being

Join our new commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies

Comments

1/1Is it safe to eat 1,200 calories a day?

Is it safe to eat 1,200 calories a day?

'For some women it could temporarily shut down their fertility.'

Subscribe to Independent Premium to bookmark this article

Want to bookmark your favourite articles and stories to read or reference later? Start your Independent Premium subscription today.

Subscribe
Already subscribed? Log in

Trending

Featured

Voucher Codes
Boots Discount Code
Up to 10% off your order when you sign up at Boots
Feel Unique Discount Code
20% off everything with this Feel Unique discount code 2021
Nike Discount Code
Enjoy 25% off your birthday - Nike discount code for members only
Footasylum Discount Code
Extra 20% off outlet items with this Footasylum discount code
Gousto Discount Codes
Gousto discount code: 1st box 60% + 1st month 30% off

Video